Nearly two years after the discovery of ancient human remains outside a home on Withrow Avenue, Toronto officials and archeologists believe they have uncovered evidence of a communal grave containing at least five individuals. Lisa Merritt, an archeologist working on the investigation, explained that the findings included teeth and various parts of skeletons, indicating the presence of multiple people buried together.
The human bones were unearthed on January 5, 2024, during a routine pipe replacement project on Withrow Avenue. Subsequent examinations revealed that the remains were of Indigenous origin, adding to the complexity of the archaeological site. Artifacts dating back as far as 5,000 years and a possible 700-year-old communal burial chamber have been identified in the area.
The investigation, which involves meticulous screening of soil samples, has been a collaborative effort between the City of Toronto, archeological experts, and multiple First Nations communities. The Ontario government is expected to approve a detailed excavation plan, with the goal of completing the process by early 2026. The City has allocated significant resources, with approximately $517,000 spent on site security and preservation measures.
While most First Nations stakeholders have agreed on the investigative process, some organizations, like the Haudenosaunee Development Institute (HDI), have expressed concerns and proposed alternative approaches. Tanya Hill-Montour, representing the Six Nations of the Grand River, emphasized the need for collaboration and respect for the historical significance of the site.
As the excavation work continues, the importance of honoring and understanding the ancestral heritage of the area remains a focal point for all involved parties.

