A Montreal surgeon is advocating for changes to the Jacques Cartier monument-fountain in the Sud-Ouest borough, deeming it disrespectful to Indigenous communities.
Dr. Stanley Vollant is pushing for modifications to two aspects of the fountain in Saint-Henri park: the Indigenous effigies and a particular plaque.
The issue first caught Vollant’s attention in the summer of 2020 when his young daughter pointed out the Indigenous faces depicted on the fountain. Seeing these figures spitting out water, Vollant had a poignant conversation with his daughter, explaining the historical context and the need for change.
Rather than calling for the fountain’s removal, Dr. Vollant suggests a simple alteration by removing the Indigenous effigies. He believes a collaborative effort can lead to a more culturally sensitive representation without compromising the fountain’s aesthetic.
The monument, erected in 1893 to honor Jacques Cartier, carries a plaque that references Cartier’s claim of the land in the name of the king, a statement Vollant finds deeply offensive to Indigenous peoples.
Heritage Montreal acknowledges the historical context but Dr. Vollant urges for a rewriting of the plaque to reflect a more respectful narrative towards Indigenous communities.
The office of the Sud-Ouest borough mayor has indicated a willingness to engage in discussions with Indigenous representatives to address the concerns raised by Dr. Vollant and work towards finding a solution that respects both Indigenous and non-Indigenous perspectives.
Dr. Vollant emphasizes the importance of collaboration and a balanced approach to reconciliation, highlighting the need for mutual understanding and respect in this process.
